Our Best Features
Learn how to determine if you're an exempt vs nonexempt employee, spot an unpaid overtime claim, and understand salaried employee overtime rights. Get steps to check the salary basis test, document misclassified exempt employee claims, and when to contact an FLSA overtime lawyer for salary basis test legal help.
Estimated reading time: 12 minutes
Key Takeaways
Exempt vs nonexempt determines overtime and minimum wage protections under the FLSA.
The salary basis test and duties test both must be met for an employee to be exempt.
Salaried status alone does not guarantee exemption — many salaried workers are nonexempt.
Document hours, pay stubs, and communications to preserve potential unpaid overtime claims.
Consult a wage and hour attorney or file a DOL complaint if you suspect misclassification or improper deductions.
Table of Contents
Introduction: Exempt vs Nonexempt Employee—Why It Matters Now
Section 1: Understanding Exempt vs Nonexempt Employee Classification
Section 2: The Salary Basis Test—Salary Basis Test Legal Help and Legal Implications
Section 3: Salaried Employee Overtime Rights—What Applies to an Exempt vs Nonexempt Employee
Section 4: Identifying an Unpaid Overtime Claim as a Misclassified Exempt Employee
Section 5: Taking Action with a FLSA Overtime Lawyer and Salary Basis Test Legal Help
Conclusion: Exempt vs Nonexempt Employee—Recap, Salaried Employee Overtime Rights, and How a FLSA Overtime Lawyer Can Help
FAQ
Introduction: Exempt vs Nonexempt Employee—Why It Matters Now
Understanding the difference between an exempt vs nonexempt employee is critical under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). The classification controls whether you are entitled to overtime pay and minimum wage protections.
An exempt employee is not entitled to FLSA overtime or minimum wage. These employees typically hold white-collar roles—executive, administrative, professional, computer, or outside sales—and are paid a salary at or above the FLSA’s salary threshold. A nonexempt employee is entitled to overtime premium pay (at least 1.5 times the regular rate) for all hours worked over 40 in a workweek. Classification affects your paycheck, your working hours, your wage and hour protections, and your legal options if you’re not paid lawfully. See sources at the end of this section.
In this guide, you will learn how to:
Determine if you are exempt or nonexempt
Spot the signs of an unpaid overtime claim
Understand salaried employee overtime rights
Know when to contact a FLSA overtime lawyer and when to seek salary basis test legal help
If you suspect misclassification or wage theft learn more here, this step-by-step resource helps you move from confusion to action.
Sources for this section:
Section 1: Understanding Exempt vs Nonexempt Employee Classification
Classification is not a title or a guess—it is a legal determination based on federal wage and hour law. Getting it right matters for overtime, minimum wage, and back pay claims.
What makes someone an exempt employee
- Exempt status means the employee is not covered by FLSA overtime or minimum wage requirements.
- These are usually white-collar exemptions: executive, administrative, professional, computer employee, or outside sales.
- Exempt status is never automatic. Exemption requires meeting both the salary threshold and the duties test for a specific exemption category.
Key exemptions and real-world examples
- Executive exemption:
Primary duty is managing a department or the enterprise.
Regularly directs at least two full-time employees (or equivalent).
Has genuine input into hiring, firing, and personnel decisions.
Example: A store manager who schedules staff, sets budgets, and supervises 3 shift leads.
- Administrative exemption:
Primary duty is office or non-manual work directly related to management or general business operations.
Exercises discretion and independent judgment on significant matters.
Example: An HR generalist who develops policies, not a receptionist who follows set procedures.
- Professional exemption:
Learned professionals rely on advanced knowledge in a field of science or learning, usually acquired by prolonged specialized education (e.g., CPA, RN, architect).
Creative professionals perform work requiring invention, imagination, originality, or talent in a recognized artistic field.
- Computer employee exemption:
Applies to certain high-level computer systems analysts, programmers, or software engineers.
Note: Not all IT roles qualify; help-desk or hardware techs often do not meet this exemption.
- Outside sales exemption:
Primary duty is making sales away from the employer’s place of business.
Example: A traveling sales representative who spends most time visiting clients off-site.
These categories and examples are common, but the details matter. Employers must align actual job duties—not just job titles—with the exemption criteria.
What makes someone a nonexempt employee
- Nonexempt employees are covered by all FLSA protections.
- They must receive overtime pay at time-and-a-half for all hours over 40 in a workweek.
- Nonexempt workers are often paid hourly, but they can also be salaried. Salary alone does not create exemption.
The salary basis test and the salary threshold
- Exempt employees must be paid on a salary basis, meaning a predetermined, fixed salary each workweek that is not reduced based on quality or quantity of work.
- That salary must meet or exceed the FLSA’s minimum salary threshold:
$684 per week until June 30, 2024
$844 per week from July 1, 2024
$1,128 per week from January 1, 2025
- If pay is below the threshold at any point in the applicable timeframe, the employee typically cannot be exempt and may be due overtime.
- If an employer fails the salary basis test (for example, through improper deductions), the worker may be a misclassified exempt employee and may need salary basis test legal help to recover unpaid wages.
Why exempt vs nonexempt employee status matters
- Getting classification wrong can lead to:
Lost overtime pay view resource
Minimum wage shortfalls
Wage theft claims and penalties
Class or collective actions for back pay and damages view resource
- Workers should confirm both their salary level and their actual job duties match an exemption.
Quick self-check for classification
- Do your daily tasks match one of the exemption categories above?
- Is your weekly salary at or above the current FLSA threshold?
- Is your pay fixed and not docked for variations in quality/quantity of work?
- If you answered “no” to any, you may be nonexempt—or misclassified as exempt.
Keywords used: exempt vs nonexempt employee, salary basis test legal help, misclassified exempt employee
Sources for this section:
Section 2: The Salary Basis Test—Salary Basis Test Legal Help and Legal Implications
The salary basis test is often decisive in whether a worker is exempt. It evaluates how you are paid and whether your pay can be improperly reduced.
What the salary basis test requires
- A fixed, predetermined salary:
You must receive the same base salary each workweek, regardless of hours worked or the amount/quality of work performed.
- No improper deductions:
Employers generally cannot dock pay for partial-day absences, variations in work output, or minor infractions.
- Meeting or exceeding the salary threshold:
$684 per week until June 30, 2024
$844 per week from July 1, 2024
$1,128 per week from January 1, 2025
When an employer fails the salary basis test
- Paying below the FLSA salary threshold during the relevant period.
- Making improper salary deductions for:
Partial-day absences (for most categories)
Shortfalls in work quantity
Minor rule violations
- Applying the wrong exemption where job duties don’t fit.
If the test is not met, you may be a misclassified exempt employee—labeled as exempt but legally nonexempt—which can unlock overtime eligibility and a strong unpaid overtime claim.
Common misclassification scenarios
- Salary below the threshold:
Example: You’re called “exempt” but paid $800/week in September 2024—below $844/week—so you don’t meet the threshold for that period.
- Improper deductions:
Example: Your employer reduces your salary for leaving work two hours early, even though you worked most of the day.
- Duties don’t match the exemption:
Example: You’re labeled “administrative,” but your work is primarily routine data entry with no discretion on significant matters.
- Inflated job titles:
Example: “Assistant Manager” who does not supervise two or more employees or make real personnel decisions.
Legal and financial impact of failing the salary basis test
- You may be reclassified as nonexempt and owed:
Back overtime pay (time-and-a-half for hours over 40)
Liquidated damages in some cases
Attorneys’ fees and costs in litigation
- Employers may face:
Civil penalties
Government investigations
Class/collective action exposure
Next steps if you suspect a violation
- Preserve your records (timesheets, pay stubs, emails).
- Conduct a short self-audit of salary, deductions, and duties. Learn more here
- Seek salary basis test legal help. A wage and hour attorney can assess deductions, evaluate duties vs. titles, and calculate the unpaid overtime claim value.
Keywords used: salary basis test legal help, misclassified exempt employee, unpaid overtime claim
Sources for this section:
Section 3: Salaried Employee Overtime Rights—What Applies to an Exempt vs Nonexempt Employee
“Salaried” does not automatically mean “exempt.” Salaried status is only part of the equation. To be exempt from overtime, an employee must meet both the salary basis and the duties test.
When salaried employees get overtime
- Salaried nonexempt employees must be paid overtime for hours worked over 40 in a workweek.
- Salaried exempt employees are not due overtime—but only if they meet both the FLSA salary requirements and the duties test for a specific exemption.
- If you are salaried but your duties are routine, you may still be nonexempt and entitled to time-and-a-half.
How to tell if you are a salaried nonexempt employee
- Your salary is set below the current threshold for the applicable date range.
- Your employer makes improper deductions that undermine the salary basis.
- Your job duties are production-based, routine, or tightly scripted with little discretion on significant matters.
- You do not supervise two or more employees and have limited say in hiring/firing.
- You work more than 40 hours and receive no overtime compensation.
Common misconceptions about salaried employee overtime rights
- Myth: “If I get a salary, I’m not eligible for overtime.” Reality: Salary is only one test. Many salaried workers are nonexempt and must receive overtime.
- Myth: “My title says manager, so I must be exempt.” Reality: The content of your job duties—not the title—drives the exemption.
- Myth: “I never track my hours because I’m salaried.” Reality: You should track your hours if you suspect nonexempt status or unpaid overtime. Documentation helps validate your claim.
- Myth: “If I agree to a fixed salary, I waive overtime.” Reality: The FLSA guarantees overtime rights for nonexempt workers, regardless of private agreements.
What this means for your paycheck
- If you’re salaried nonexempt and regularly work 45–55 hours a week, unpaid overtime may add up quickly.
- Time-and-a-half is calculated using your regular rate of pay. For a fixed salary, the regular rate often equals salary divided by total hours worked in the week; your overtime is then 1.5 times that regular rate for hours over 40.
Action steps to confirm your salaried employee overtime rights
- Compare your weekly salary to the current threshold.
- List your core duties and compare them to the exemption standards (executive, administrative, professional, computer, outside sales).
- Review your pay for overtime premiums when you work over 40 hours.
- If something doesn’t add up, you may have an unpaid overtime claim.
Keywords used: salaried employee overtime rights, exempt vs nonexempt employee, unpaid overtime claim
Sources for this section:
Section 4: Identifying an Unpaid Overtime Claim as a Misclassified Exempt Employee
You don’t need to be an expert to spot problems. A clear, methodical review of your hours, pay, and duties can reveal whether you may have an unpaid overtime claim.
How to recognize an unpaid overtime claim
- Hours over 40 with no time-and-a-half:
Review timesheets, schedules, or calendar entries.
Compare recorded hours to pay stubs.
If you worked over 40 hours and were paid the same salary with no overtime premium, that’s a red flag.
- Salary below the threshold for dates when the threshold increased:
Confirm whether you earned at least $684/week until June 30, 2024; $844/week starting July 1, 2024; and $1,128/week starting January 1, 2025.
If paid below those amounts, you may be nonexempt during the affected period and owed overtime.
- Duties don’t match the claimed exemption:
List your daily tasks. Are you managing, or mostly doing routine production work?
Do you install/repair/enter data rather than create policy, set budgets, or direct operations?
- Improper salary deductions:
Look for reductions based on partial-day absences, short hours, or minor infractions.
Salary docking that violates the salary basis test can undo your exempt status.
Common signs of wage theft or misclassification
- You are told you are “exempt,” but:
You don’t supervise staff or influence hiring/firing (executive exemption failure).
Your role is entry-level or production-focused with little discretion (administrative exemption failure).
Your work doesn’t require advanced, specialized education or creative output (professional exemption failure).
You perform computer support but not systems analysis or software engineering duties (computer exemption failure).
You mainly sell by phone or from the office, not “outside” in the field (outside sales exemption failure).
Documenting your unpaid overtime claim
- Maintain a personal log of hours:
Use notes, emails, calendar invites, or work app timestamps.
Capture off-the-clock work like after-hours emails, on-call time, or pre-shift tasks.
- Save pay records:
Pay stubs, direct deposit statements, bonus policies, and any written pay rules.
- Preserve communications:
HR emails, job descriptions, schedules, and messages showing required overtime or coverage.
- Summarize the gaps:
List weeks where you worked 40+ hours without overtime.
Note weeks where the salary threshold was not met.
What to do if you’re a misclassified exempt employee
- Ask HR for your exemption basis in writing (executive, administrative, etc.).
- Compare your duties to the exemption tests and salary threshold.
- Consult a wage and hour attorney for an independent assessment, especially if you suspect improper deductions or thresholds not met.
Keywords used: unpaid overtime claim, misclassified exempt employee, exempt vs nonexempt employee
Sources for this section:
Section 5: Taking Action with a FLSA Overtime Lawyer and Salary Basis Test Legal Help
When you’re unsure about your classification—or when money is clearly missing from your paychecks—it’s time to get help. A FLSA overtime lawyer can turn scattered records into a focused legal strategy.
When to consult a FLSA overtime lawyer
- You worked over 40 hours in multiple weeks without overtime pay.
- Your salary fell under the applicable FLSA threshold.
- Your employer docked your salary for partial-day absences or minor issues.
- Your job duties do not match the claimed exemption.
- HR won’t explain or correct your classification.
- You need salary basis test legal help to verify deductions or threshold gaps.
What a wage and hour attorney will do
- Case assessment:
Review job descriptions, real duties, schedules, and pay stubs.
Apply the salary basis test and the duties test to your role.
Estimate unpaid overtime and potential damages.
- Strategy and filing:
Prepare a demand letter, a DOL complaint, or a lawsuit depending on the facts.
Assemble evidence of misclassification and improper pay practices.
- Negotiation and resolution:
Engage your employer to resolve the claim via settlement, mediation, or litigation.
Seek back pay, liquidated damages where available, and attorneys’ fees.
- Ongoing guidance:
Explain timelines, documentation needs, and what to expect at each phase.
Legal options and possible outcomes
- Department of Labor (DOL) complaint:
The Wage and Hour Division can investigate and seek back wages on your behalf.
- Private lawsuit:
You can pursue unpaid overtime, damages, and fees in court.
- Individual vs. group actions:
If coworkers were misclassified the same way, a collective action may increase leverage and efficiency.
Practical tips to strengthen your claim
- Organize your records by week.
- Prepare a concise timeline of events (job start date, title changes, pay changes, threshold increases).
- Keep communications professional and factual when discussing with HR or management.
- Do not delete emails or messages related to schedules, duties, and pay.
Seek salary basis test legal help learn more here to understand your options and protect your rights.
Setting expectations
- Timeline varies based on the employer’s response and complexity.
- Most cases hinge on clear documentation and accurate calculation of hours.
- An attorney’s role is to protect your rights and maximize recovery under the FLSA.
Keywords used: FLSA overtime lawyer, salary basis test legal help, misclassified exempt employee, unpaid overtime claim
Sources for this section:
Conclusion: Exempt vs Nonexempt Employee—Recap, Salaried Employee Overtime Rights, and How a FLSA Overtime Lawyer Can Help
Knowing whether you are an exempt vs nonexempt employee determines your overtime pay, minimum wage protections, and your legal remedies. Many workers are salaried but still nonexempt. If you exceed 40 hours in a workweek, you may be entitled to overtime—even with a fixed salary.
Key steps to protect yourself
- Self-assess your status:
Compare your job duties to the executive, administrative, professional, computer, and outside sales exemptions.
Confirm your salary meets the FLSA threshold for the relevant dates.
- Track and document:
Keep detailed time logs and save pay stubs and HR communications.
- Understand salaried employee overtime rights:
Salary alone does not eliminate overtime pay obligations.
- Seek help when needed:
If you suspect misclassification, consider salary basis test legal help and consult a FLSA overtime lawyer to explore claims for unpaid overtime.
- Take action:
File a DOL complaint or pursue a legal claim to recover back pay and damages.
You deserve fair pay for every hour worked. If there’s any doubt about your classification or your unpaid wages, the right legal support can help you move quickly and confidently.
Call to action
Get a free, instant case evaluation from US Employment Lawyers. See if your case qualifies within 30 seconds at employmentlawyers.com. It’s fast, confidential, and can help you understand your overtime rights today.
Keywords used: exempt vs nonexempt employee, salaried employee overtime rights, FLSA overtime lawyer, salary basis test legal help, unpaid overtime claim
Sources for this section:
FAQ
What is the difference between an exempt and nonexempt employee?
An exempt employee is not entitled to FLSA overtime or minimum wage protections and typically meets both the salary basis test and the duties test for a white-collar exemption. A nonexempt employee is covered by FLSA protections and must receive overtime pay at time-and-a-half for hours worked over 40 in a workweek.
Does being salaried mean I am exempt from overtime?
No. Salaried status alone does not make you exempt. To be exempt, you must meet the salary basis test (fixed salary at or above the threshold) and the duties test for a specific exemption category.
What should I do if my employer makes improper salary deductions?
Preserve pay stubs, timesheets, and communications. Conduct a short self-audit of salary and deductions, and consider seeking salary basis test legal help or consulting a wage and hour attorney to assess potential unpaid overtime claims.
When should I contact a FLSA overtime lawyer?
Consult a FLSA overtime lawyer if you regularly worked over 40 hours without overtime pay, your salary fell below the applicable FLSA threshold, your employer docked your salary improperly, your duties don’t match the claimed exemption, or HR will not correct your classification.
How can I file a complaint about unpaid wages?
You can file a Department of Labor (DOL) Wage and Hour Division complaint or pursue a private lawsuit. Gathering thorough documentation (timesheets, pay stubs, communications) and consulting an attorney will strengthen your claim.
